DNF Review of Stone Field by Christy Lenzi

StoneFieldStone Field
By: Christy Lenzi
Release Date: March 29th 2016
Publisher: Roaring Brook Press
Format: Print ARC
Source: Publisher

I DNFed at page 105

In a small town on the brink of the Civil War, Catrina finds a man making strange patterns in her family’s sorghum crop. He’s mad with fever, naked, and strikingly beautiful. He has no memory of who he is or what he’s done before Catrina found him in Stone Field. But that doesn’t bother Catrina because she doesn’t like thinking about the things she’s done before either.

Catrina and Stonefield fall passionately, dangerously, in love. All they want is to live with each other, in harmony with the land and away from Cat’s protective brother, the new fanatical preacher, and the neighbors who are scandalized by their relationship. But Stonefield can’t escape the truth about who he is, and the conflict tearing apart the country demands that everyone take a side before the bloodbath reaches their doorstep.

My Thoughts:
I really want to love this book because the summary sounded amazing. Things started off pretty well. I enjoyed Lenzi’s writing and I was impressed that the main character didn’t fit into societal rules of her time period. She smoked a pipe, ran in the woods and really didn’t fit into polite society.

Sadly, the further I got the less I was enjoying the story. After Cat meets the strange, naked man on her land things started going haywire. I’d heard that there was some major insta-love going on. I was prepared and thinking I’d be able to cope with it. But…it wasn’t just insta-love/lust it was instant CONNECTION. And not only the ‘I feel I’ve known you forever’ but literal telepathy…it was too much. If there’s going to be a paranormal element I need some explanation. After 100 pages I still had no clue how these two were communicating this way- I think it was just supposed to be accepted as how things were. I just couldn’t suspend my sense of reality.

I was interested in the time period the novel takes place during but I was having trouble with everything else. Did you read this? What were your thoughts?


  1. says

    I actually didn’t read this one, but Erin did. She mentioned that that there was some insta-love. I moved this off my tbr after she said I wouldn’t like it . 🙂 sometimes it’s nice to have a validator LOL 🙂 Sorry you didn’t enjoy it!


    • says

      Did Erin like it? Yeah, I thought I could handle the insta-love because that’s not something that irritates me straight out but ugh. It was too much for me.

  2. says

    I actually enjoyed this one for the most part. I’m like you though, these days I will DNF if I just get to a point where I can’t keep going. It’s not worth the time wasted to finish something I’m not enjoying when there are so many other books out there to read still! Great review!

    • says

      I’m glad you liked this one! Should I have stuck with it? I just felt like things were taken too far. I totally agree with DNFing.

  3. says

    Aw, I’m so sorry that you had to DNF this book sweetie :\ That suuucks. Sounds like it was pretty bad, lol. I don’t think this would be a book for me either, sadly. You are awesome for managing to stop reading it 🙂 Yay. Thank you for sharing your reasons. <3 Hugs.

  4. says

    It’s interesting to hear that this book had so much going on. I heard it was a retelling of Wuthering Heights so I knew it wasn’t going to work for me (I really, really didn’t like Wuthering Heights) but it’s always sad to hear when a book doesn’t hit the mark compared to its synopsis. Alas.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *